Scales and Gavel

The Value of Legal Information in Divorce Mediation4 min read

Although a mediator should never provide “legal counsel or advice” to either party, a good divorce mediator may need to provide the parties with basic legal information or specific legal rules that are applicable to the disputed issues in their case. Sometimes when parties have an early proposal for resolving a particular issue in their case, they will quickly abandon their original proposal when they are presented with the “vanilla version” of the law by their mediator. If they discover that their proposed division of a particular asset or asset group is not supported by the law, they may immediately want to resolve the issue in a more equitable manner.

For example, when the parties learn that retirement assets earned during the marriage are community property, the husband and wife who have previously agreed that each party should keep his or her entire retirement assets earned during the marriage may reconsider their proposed division when they realize that the proposed division is inconsistent with the law and will result in an unequal division of the marital property. If the value of the wife’s retirement assets greatly exceeds the value of her husband’s retirement assets, the wife may become upset with the mediator for providing this legal information, but despite the fact the legal information favors one party over the other, this information must be made available to the parties if they are going to negotiate fairly and wisely regarding the division of the retirement assets earned during the marriage. If the couple proceeds with the proposed marital property division without being apprised of the law regarding retirement assets, the party who suffers the loss of his or her full community interest in the retirement assets will not be satisfied with the mediation process and worse, may suffer unnecessary financial hardship.

The parties can always proceed with their original agreement once they know the legal rules, but it is important that they be informed of the rights that they may be giving up before they proceed with the unequal division. The mediator should also consider referring the parties to a consulting attorney and a retirement valuation expert if there are additional legal and/or financial issues that affect the application of the general 50% rule. When there may be loans taken against a 401k, when the retirement asset has been accumulated both before the marriage as well as after the marriage, or if there are undervalued traditional pensions of significant value, the “vanilla version” of the law will not be sufficient for the parties to make an informed decision regarding the proposed division of their retirement benefits.

After learning about the characterization and value of their retirement assets the parties are free to agree to a more equitable division and not proceed with their earlier proposal, or they may agree to confirm their initial proposal. What matters is not whether they apply the legal rule in their case, but that they are aware of the laws that pertain to their decision and know the value of the assets before they make a final decision regarding this important part of their settlement.

Unfortunately, sometimes when a mediator provides the “vanilla version” of the law, it is hard to maintain the mediator’s appearance of neutrality when the law happens to favor one party’s position over the other party’s position. There is a tendency by many mediators to be too conservative and cautious regarding the communication of legal information to the parties. They fear that they may be crossing the line between giving “legal advice” and providing the parties with permissible “legal information.” There are several ways to provide legal information to assure that the mediator does not cross the line and venture into legal advice. One way is to provide handouts to both parties that summarize some basic legal rules at the commencement of the mediation, or during the mediation to simply provide both parties with the text of a particular statute or quote the definitive legal rule that applies to their issue. The more conservative mediator may simply refer the couple to a consulting attorney at the beginning of the case so that they avoid even the possibility of being deemed to have provided impermissible legal advice to the parties.

Despite the potential downside, legal information is an essential and valuable tool for mediators to provide the parties so that there will be integrity and transparency in the parties’ decision-making.

Similar Posts

  • Managing Anger in Mediation

    As a divorce mediator working with divorcing couples for over 30 years, I have learned that helping clients manage their anger during the divorce process is often the most effective tool in facilitating my clients’ settlement process. Anger can hijack the parties’ ability to think clearly, leading to poor judgment and decision making. Spouses with hot tempers do foolish things. If expressions of anger are not controlled during the mediation process anger causes mistakes that the parties will regret later.  Anger is not static and if one party’s anger is not controlled anger is often contagious. Your clients always lose when they lose their tempers, and they can get stuck in the crisis and chaos of divorce instead of focusing on how to problem solve and…

  • Follow the Yellow Brick Road – A Hero’s Journey to Settlement Success

    n his book, “Follow the Yellow Brick Road – How to Change for the Better When Life Gives You its Worst”, Dr. Sam Alibrando describes several practices that enabled Dorothy to take a hero’s journey when a twister took her away from her familiar life in Kansas and landed her in the Land of Oz. Divorce is like a twister for many couples, unexpected, scary, dangerous and unsettling. Dr. Alibrando tells us “The hero’s journey turns adversity into growth. This is the hero’s journey and the road the hero takes is paved with yellow brick.” Along the yellow brick road, Dorothy encounters the Knowing Scarecrow, the Courageous Lion, and the Loving Tin Man. With the help of her three companions, and their corresponding gifts of…

  • Avoid the Sting of Divorce Litigation

    Many divorce litigation attorneys are highly skilled and knowledgeable about family law and may be Certified Family Law Specialists. Litigation attorneys often reassure their clients that they will fight for them and secure all they are entitled to in the divorce. A spouse going through a divorce will often find that their litigation attorney is comforting, caring, and understanding, but litigation attorneys like the great boxing champion, Mohammed Ali, are trained to fight. They may look like butterflies, but they can sting like bees. Attorneys are first trained to fight in law school, where they learn how to persuade, negotiate, apply pressure, and use the strength of the law to convince a Judge to make a ruling in their client’s favor. Their law professors teach…

  • Divorce Mediation – Empowering Wise Decision Making

    Whether you mediate or litigate your divorce the process is one that involves decision making. The decisions that parties must make will be in three main areas: Parenting, Dividing Marital Assets and Financial Support. Couples who choose a cooperative mediated process will be able to make their own decisions and control the outcome of the divorce process. The key to wise decision making requires that the parties take the time to educate themselves on the facts and the laws that apply to their case. Good decision making requires that the parties manage their emotions, engage in financial planning and when there are children involved they must consider how the divorce process and their parenting plan will impact the welfare of their children. In order to…

  • The “Vanilla Version” of the Law in Divorce Mediation

    Even though a mediator should never provide legal counsel to either party, a good divorce mediator will often need to provide their clients with basic legal information or specific legal rules that are undisputedly applicable to a particular marital asset. Sometimes when my clients have a proposal for dividing a particular asset in their marital estate, they will quickly abandon their original proposal when they become informed of what I refer to as the “vanilla version” of the law. The parties may discover that one or both will want to resolve the disposition of the asset differently once they become informed of the applicable legal rules. For example, a couple comes to mediation and informs their mediator that they have agreed that each spouse will keep…

  • What is the Identity of a Divorce Mediator?

    It is often said that the dominant culture of divorce is an adversarial one. A culture where winning and losing is the name of the game and that divorce is war. Family attorneys most often identify with the litigation community. If family litigation is the prevailing divorce culture then the family mediation community is a counter culture. The way one identifies with a community or culture is to look at the following factors: 1) How do the members of the culture or community behave; 2) What do its members believe, and 3) To what organizations do they belong? The members of the Family Mediation Community behave in a manner that fosters consensual and amicable decision making. They act in ways that encourage problem solving, and…